Conversation Help · Relationship

My Partner Thinks Our Relationship Is Fine but I Don’t

Sometimes the hardest relationship conversation isn't one where both people know something is wrong. It's one where only one of you seems to know it. Your partner may be perfectly content.

Meanwhile, you're thinking:

How can you possibly think we're fine? That difference can make you feel even more alone. But it also creates a trap. If you start the conversation by trying to prove that the relationship is objectively bad, your partner may spend the whole conversation trying to prove that it isn't. Then you're arguing about whether there's a problem instead of talking about the problem.

Your experience doesn't require their agreement

Suppose your partner says:

“We don't fight much.” “We just went away together.” “We have sex.” “We laugh all the time.” “I thought everything was good.” Those things may all be true. And you may still feel unhappy, disconnected or dissatisfied. You don't need to establish that the relationship is terrible before you're allowed to want something to change.

Try:

“I know this may surprise you because I don't think you've been experiencing things the same way. But I haven't been feeling good about us lately, and I don't want to keep that from you.” That doesn't tell your partner they're oblivious. It tells them something important about your experience that they didn't know.

Be careful with “How could you not know?”

It's understandable. You've been feeling this way for months. Maybe you've dropped hints. Maybe you've seemed withdrawn. Maybe you've complained about pieces of the problem. Surely they noticed. Maybe they didn't. People are remarkably capable of living in the same relationship and experiencing it differently.

If your partner says:

THEY SAY: “I honestly thought we were doing great.”

Try not to answer:

“Then you haven't been paying attention.”

Try:

“I believe you. And I probably haven't been as direct about how I've been feeling as I should have been. That's why I'm trying to talk about it now.” That doesn't mean you're taking responsibility for the entire problem. You're taking responsibility for making sure the problem is finally clear.

Don't demand that they feel what you feel

Your partner may not feel lonely. They may not miss more time together. They may be perfectly comfortable with the amount of affection, conversation, sex or independence in the relationship. That difference itself may be the issue.

The productive question becomes:

Can we understand what each of us needs and find a relationship that works better for both of us?

That's very different from:

Which one of us has the correct assessment of our relationship?

Give them something concrete to respond to

“I don't think our relationship is good” invites an argument. “I miss spending time together when we're not talking about work, bills or what needs to get done” invites a conversation.

So does:

“I'd like us to have one evening a week when we're actually together rather than sitting in the same room doing separate things.”

Or:

“I want us to be more affectionate outside of sex.”

Or:

“I need us to find a better way to handle disagreements because I've started avoiding bringing things up.” Specific doesn't mean small. It means understandable.

Their surprise may take time

You've had weeks or months to think about this. Your partner may have had thirty seconds. Don't expect them to instantly produce a thoughtful response to something you've been privately processing for a long time. They may need time to absorb it. That's okay—as long as “I need time” doesn't become “therefore we never talk about this again.”

You can say:

“I understand that this is a lot to hear when you weren't expecting it. We don't have to figure everything out right now. But this is important to me, so I do want us to keep talking about it.” Now you're not demanding immediate agreement. But you're also not allowing the conversation to disappear.

Want help with the whole conversation?

“WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT OUR RELATIONSHIP” — $11.95
A Conversation Companion for Talking With Your Partner When Something Between You Isn’t Working
Five ways to start the conversation.
They Say / You Say situations — realistic reactions, better responses, and what to ask next.
How to describe what isn’t working even when you don’t yet know the solution.
How to talk about disconnection, recurring conflict, resentment and failed attempts at change.
What to do if the conversation reveals that you want different things.
GET THE COMPLETE GUIDE — $11.95
GET “WE NEED TO TALK ABOUT OUR RELATIONSHIP”